Turn on your oven to broil.

Add the butter to a medium skillet and apply medium-high heat.

Using a Halloween Cookie Cutter, cut out Halloween shapes from 2 slices of the bread. Keep the cut outs.

Place a slice of cheese on top of the whole slice of bread then place the slice with a shape cut out on top. Place both cheese sandwiches in the skillet with the hot butter for about 2 minutes.

While that side of the bread is cooking, take the remaining butter and spread it on the top pieces of bread.

Once the underneath is cooked enough, place the sandwiches on a baking sheet and place under the broiler for another 2 minutes. Keep your eye on the grilled cheese to avoid burning.

Once browned enough, remove from the oven and serve. Optionally, add two little dots for eyes using sparkle gel or sliced black olives.